Well, seeing as the entire world is focussing on the economy (and rightly so), it's slightly unusual that people are divided over whether to let firms fall or support them. Do we support them and secure jobs, or let them fall and allow the continuation of the capitalist model - even though we know it's fundamentally broken but treat it like it isn't?
Now, while I'd usually favour allowing bad businesses to fall, the one's which are truly badly run (or produce nothing of quality) seem to hit a certain level of notability or profit and then cease to run into the same monopolistic pressures that most libertarians would hope they would. Is this because they actually produce something people need? Possibly. In the case of EA, while they do produce an endless stream of updates of pretty terrible sports games, long and over done franchises that ceased to be enjoyable - and of course the Sims and Spore, but those are the most pirated games for a reason - they do a considerable service to the gaming industry in the form of publisher: they're an absolutely monolithic publisher of video games, publishing incredibly successful games such as Crysis, Battlefield 2 and Rock Band, to name a few.
Now, if this company is not going to be threatened by the credit crisis significantly despite developing little content worth playing (unless you're a sports game fan, but I'll never understand that), does this mean that it is inherently well run? Surely companies should fail if they are badly run or fail to produce quality products, so why haven't they failed? More to the point, why have they (like so many other software companies) thrived by gobbling up smaller companies?
Fundamentally, when small businesses that rely on a solid line of credit are getting screwed despite being well run, it is hard to understand the position of 'let the market take its course'. When you help usher in a broken system that has almost no impact on the companies that selective pressure should impact (or is obliged to bail out large companies because their failure would be catastrophic - surely any firm should be replaceable?) it is time to reassess what you believe is and isn't broken.
Now, some of the strangest objections to the $825bn stimulus pack I've heard are that it's going to the wrong people - that less should be spent on food stamps and planned parentcy (which was cut from it, but including it would have been economically advantageous, even if it wouldn't be politically savvy). I'm sorry, but what? Less on food stamps? Considering that food security in the US dropped between 2000-2004 (http://usfoodpolicy.blogspot.com/2005/10/household-food-insecurity-deteriorated.html) and that a large portion of Americans are currently relying on food stamps to survive (http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/usa-2008-the-great-depression-803095.html 28 million estimated for 2009 in April 2008), the idea of not boosting cash to folks on food stamps because 'some of them' are long term unemployed and just loving their benefit checks so they can do their best never to work an honest day in their life. I'd like to know what percentage of 28 million 'some of them' are, personally, as nearly 10% of the US population is hardly a thing to ignore.
'Short-term unemployment was more likely among younger people. Long-term unemployment was more likely among older men.
People with higher qualifications were likely to experience shorter lengths of unemployment.
Some 34 per cent of unemployed people with disabilities were long-term unemployed compared with 20 per cent for people with no disabilities.
For unemployed people with dependent children, lone parents were more likely to be long-term unemployed than heads of family in a married/cohabiting couple with dependent children (30 per cent and 26 per cent respectively).'
(Source: www.statistics.gov.uk/articles/labour_market_trends/unemp_in_brief.pdf)
While I am loath to bring up the moral argument about whether investing more in planned pregnancy would also serve to reduce the number of lone mothers who are long term unemployed, it's quite hard to say to someone in their 50's that they should 'get on their bike' and take whatever work they can get, especially if they have a family to support and bills to pay.
So, while I'd love to relish in a little 'Creative Destruction', right now a stimulus package to grease the wheels in Keynesian fashion is certainly brighter than putting millions out of work and revoking the food stamps to 28 million people.
Wednesday, 28 January 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)